Aging Gut Flora

Diet selects for the bacteria that grow in the GI track and control the development of the immune system.  Diet-based inflammation produces aging symptoms.

Returning to the Subject of Aging

I want to return to the subject of aging.  A year and a half ago I wrote, “You don’t wear out, you flame out.”  I still think that is true, but I need to update that idea of inflammation and aging to include diet, gut flora and immune system development.  So here is my old article with a new focus on the gut.

Wearing Out Only Happens with Inflammation

I don’t think that aging happens -- most symptoms associated with aging are just medically mismanaged chronic inflammation.  The major observations are that older people have more degenerative/autoimmune diseases and they suffer from fewer infectious diseases.  The typical explanation is that the bodies of older people have figured out infections with an experienced immune system and that mechanical damage takes its toll over time -- joints wear out.  I think that there may be a minor amount of truth in this cultural perspective, but there is something more profound at work, sarcopenia combined with a compromised gut flora.

Replacing Muscle with Visceral Fat Is Inflammatory

Sarcopenia (muscle loss) is the gradual loss of muscle and replacement by fat.  Thus, by age fifty most people are physically less active and even if they appear to have the same weight and shape as in their active youth, the muscle of their abdomens and limbs has been partially replaced with fat.  This fat, as in those who are obese, releases inflammatory cytokines into the circulation and the body reacts as if it has a low grade infection.

Chronic Inflammation Taxes Immune System

Senior citizens are constantly expending energy and taxing their immune system by chronic inflammation.  As a result they get fewer infections, but the chronic inflammation provides the foundation for cancer and autoimmune diseases.  Their bodies aren’t mechanically wearing out, but they are wearing out by over use of the immune system.  

Aging Symptoms Are Inflammation Symptoms

Those seniors who are physically active and eat an anti-inflammatory diet, do not appear to age as fast as those who are sedentary, obese and display the typical symptoms of chronic inflammation, the metabolic syndrome.  Most of the characteristics associated with advancing years are merely symptoms of poorly managed chronic inflammation that can be reversed by an anti-inflammatory diet and exercise.

Diet Determines Gut Flora

Diet also contributes to aging, because diet controls development of gut flora and gut flora control development of the immune system.  The gut flora of an individual reflect the bacteria that have entered the GI tract, nutrients available to the bacteria in previous meals, bacterial growth regulators released by the gut, exposure to antibiotics, exposure to phytochemicals and gut transit time.

Gut Flora Is Diverse and Adaptable

Gut flora appears to be amazingly diverse from individual to individual with thousands of bacterial species inhabiting humans worldwide and about 150 species in each individual.  The same species remain in an individual for long periods of time regardless of diet.  The dominance of particular species depends on recent diet.  Major changes can result from antibiotics or gut diseases, e.g. Crohn’s.

Constipation Means Dysfunctional Gut Flora

Bowel stools are made up predominantly of bacteria and not undigested plant parts, i.e. fiber.  Fiber is made up of plant polysaccharides that are not digested by salivary, stomach or pancreatic enzymes, e.g. proteases and amylases that degrade proteins and starch.  Fiber polysaccharides pass into the colon where they are digested by gut flora.  People with constipation usually have disrupted gut flora, e.g. wiped out by antibiotics, and so the minimal volume of remaining undigested fiber is all that passes out in compact, dehydrated lumps.  If gut flora have been exposed to a particular type of fiber and bacteria having the needed enzymes have been brought into the gut previously, then the fiber is digested to sugars that feed the gut bacteria.  The increased population of bacteria is what makes up normal, hydrated bowel stools.

Gut Flora Changes Slowly to New Foods (Polysaccharides)

Bacteria grow quickly and with ample nutrients gut bacteria can double in number in about an hour.  Bacterial species are usually defined by the ability to utilize various carbohydrates or polysaccharides as nutrients.  Depending on the food eaten, nutrients favor the growth of particular bacterial species and the gut flora population changes dynamically.  New species are incorporated into the gut flora only if they find their way into the gut on food, e.g. riding on fresh, uncooked vegetables, and food provides nutrients that can permit the new bacteria to grow.  It will take several meals for new bacteria to reach appreciable numbers.  In the mean time the new fiber may be partially degraded and produce chemicals that disrupt other gut flora and cause bloating symptoms of food intolerance.  This is not an allergic reaction of the immune system.  It just takes time and persistence to permit the gut flora to adapt.  Most people systematically make themselves intolerant to particular foods by over-reacting to initial maladaption of their gut flora to the new food.  If they persisted with progressive exposure to diverse foods, their gut flora would adapt.

Simplified Aging Gut Flora Contributes to Inflammation

People of increasing age who maintain a diverse, anti-inflammatory diet and maintain muscle mass by weight-bearing exercise, avoid age-related inflammation and disease, i.e. they age more slowly.  Conversely, those who simplify their diets by eating processed foods high in starch and vegetable oils, show symptoms normally associated with advanced age, even when young.  The aging diet is inflammatory and it also produces a gut flora which is different from the youthful.

Aging Gut Flora Contributes to Disease

Constipation is an extreme example of dysfunctional gut flora and since gut bacteria are needed for the normal development of the immune system that is located in the lining of the small intestines, constipation is also an indicator of a compromised immune system.  Aging is frequently accompanied by digestive problems with one extreme being constipation.  It should not be surprising that individuals with compromised immune systems also develop numerous degenerative diseases indicative of a lack in the immunological tolerance systems that develop in the gut in response to normal gut flora.  Constipation and digestive problems are not normal signs of aging.

Eliminate Symptoms of Aging by Cultivating Gut Flora

A healthy diet, healthy gut flora, and a competent immune system are all tightly connected.  The typical symptoms of aging merely reflect an unhealthy diet and lifestyle that leads to chronic inflammation, a compromised immune system and disease.  The process of aging can be slowed by attention to the next meal.  Most people who fail to be healthy and active well into their 80’s are simply victims of bad choices (or of bad medical advice.)

Antibiotics, Gut Flora, Food Intolerance and Disease

Cattle Are Finished by Selective Killing of Gut Flora.  The Sickened Animals Store Fat that Grills Great.  People Get Metabolic Syndrome.

The likening of modern humans to potatoes sacked out on a couch is misleading.  The obesity epidemic linked to diets of processed foods more closely resembles the stumbling progression of cattle to abattoir.  Antibiotics and diet systematically lead in both feedlot and food court to gut dysbiosis, immune system failure, hormone disruption, rampant fat accumulation, physical inactivity, depression and the modern suite of chronic diseases.  Healthcare costs escalate, but vet bills, in contrast, are forestalled by a captive bolt pistol.

Background Observations

• Antibiotics kill bacteria and not humans, because the bacteria have different machinery for making proteins, nucleic acids and cell walls.
• Antibiotics kill bacterial pathogens and not viruses or fungi.
• Antibiotics kill helpful bacteria in the gut (gut flora) even more readily than pathogens.
• Antibiotics are used in meat production to alter gut flora to change animal metabolism;  e.g. cattle treated with antibiotics gain fat.  Protection from disease is secondary.
• Simple diet means simple gut flora.  Processed foods are simplified foods that simplify gut flora.
• Probiotics can replace only a small fraction of the gut flora diversity.
• Gut bacteria control the immune system development in the lining of the gut.
• Chronic antibiotic use permanently simplifies gut flora and compromises the immune system.
• The appendix stores gut bacteria as a reserve to replenish gut flora following diarrhea.
• Diseases based on inflammation and immune system intolerance result from gut dysbiosis (inadequate gut bacteria).

Antibiotics Kill Good Bacteria

This is a rant about antibiotics, not about humane actions.  Humane actions are not the point here, since I am talking about health care and not treatment of agricultural animals.  I am pleading for the rights of gut flora everywhere and antibiotics are the casual killers.  Compromised gut flora is collateral damage in attempting to eliminate bacteria characterized as pathogens.  Every time the pediatrician treats the mother by acceding to her pleas for an antibiotic prescription to silence a howling ear ache and get a good night’s sleep, or the dermatologist treats teen acne with antibiotics, billions and billions of domesticated bacteria die.

Constipation Is a Sign

Countless hours are wasted waiting, because antibiotic-depleted gut flora cannot hydrate and form normal stools.  Probiotics are gulped down, but they supply only a handful of the hundreds of bacterial species that are needed for health.  Yeasts and other fungi that are naturally resistant to antibiotics quickly replace the lost beneficial bacteria in the gut, vagina and on other body surfaces.  Surcease for simple sorrows leads to lingering and lasting laminations.  Don’t mess with mother nurture.

Damage of Antibiotic Use Is Slow

Most of the impact of antibiotic annihilation of bacteria normally present in humans is unobserved, because the deleterious effects lag months behind the initial treatment.  After all, cattle treated with antibiotics to restructure their gut flora to induce bovine obesity, appear to thrive as they rapidly gain weight and avoid symptoms of infectious diseases.  Humans on antibiotics also display fewer dental and incidental infections.  Constipation is not a high price to pay for a better mirror image.  

Antibiotics Compromise the Immune System

Unfortunately, allergies, autoimmune diseases, degenerative diseases and cancers are not usually linked to prior use of antibiotics.  There is no evidence that gut flora recovers  after antibiotic treatment, but constipation as a consequence of chronic antibiotic use is a common indicator of gut dysbiosis, collapse of normal gut flora bacterial communities.  The harbingers of inflammatory and degenerative diseases are present, but are usually discounted, because they are a common consequence of the Western diet.

Food Intolerance Reveals Inadequacies in Gut Flora

Food intolerance is a sign of depleted gut flora diversity.  Gut flora have hundreds of genes that can break down a huge diversity of polysaccharides derived from plant cell walls.  Gut flora of Japanese who routinely consume kelp have specialized enzymes to hydrolyze unusual algal sulfated polysaccharides.  Essentially all of the polysaccharides in plant fiber can be consumed by bacteria in the anaerobic environment of the colon.  Inability of individuals to digest particular food components usually results from a deficiency of the gut flora and an indication of a history of dietary simplification and antibiotic use.  Lactose intolerance, for example, results from depletion of lactose-degrading bacteria from the gut flora and can be remedied by simply eating lactose with probiotics for a couple of weeks.  Gut flora can adapt, but they need persistent exposure to diverse, i.e. non-processed, food.

Antibiotic Allergies Are Natural

Allergies develop from a combination of inflammation and compromised immunological tolerance.  Inflammation heightens processing of antigens for presentation to the immune systems, whereas loss of immunological tolerance means that aggressive immune responses are inadequately controlled.  Thus, innocuous environmental molecules are incorrectly recognized as pathogen components.  Allergies to antibiotics, such as penicillin, make sense, because the antibiotic is used to treat inflammatory infections and the antibiotic treatment eliminates the gut bacteria that are needed to develop gut lymphocytes (Tregs) to produce tolerance.  Antibiotics lay the foundation for immune system dysfunction that is central to many chronic diseases.

Healthy gut flora and a healthy immune system require:

• avoidance of antibiotics
• systematic (not simply eating yogurt) rebuilding of gut flora following diarrhea or antibiotic use; lack of an appendix means gut flora reservoir is gone
• eating a variety of vegetables; avoiding processed food
• using herbs and spices
• don’t overdo hygiene; gut flora diversity derives from bacteria that you eat and those that rub off acquaintances
• eat seasonally to increase diversity

2009: What I Learned Last Year

This year followers of this blog checked in more than 100,000 times to read my 150 articles on diet, inflammation and disease.  I learned a lot and I hope that my readers gained some insights into anti-inflammatory food choices that are helpful in pursuing enhanced health.  Here is a status report.

What We Eat Contributes More to Disease Risk than Genetics

I started this blog to try to understand how food, exercise, sun exposure, etc., contribute to health and disease, because I was shocked that recent, comprehensive studies demonstrated that genetic defects were only minor contributors.  I am trained as a molecular biologist and I search for explanations of disease in terms of the interactions of the proteins coded by the genes in our cells.  History of defective genes that code for defective proteins in sickle-cell anemia, Huntington’s disease or ALS, suggested that personal genetic defects might explain personal diseases.  Fortunately, it appears that in most cases genetic defects only matter when our actions produce chronic inflammation.  What we eat is far more important than our genetics in determining if we are going to suffer from allergies, autoimmune diseases, degenerative diseases, various forms of mental illness or cancer.  If we eat to avoid inflammation, in most cases it doesn’t matter how genetically defective we are.

Diet-Based Inflammation Is the Major Risk

Modern diets rich in starch/sugar/fructose and polyunsaturated fats (omega-6 oils), and deficient in saturated fats and omega-3 oils produce the chronic inflammation that forms the foundation of most diseases.  Vegetable oils, such as corn, soy or safflower oils are inflammatory and should be eliminated from our kitchens.  We should only use olive oil, butter or lard.  Saturated fats from meat, dairy and eggs are healthier than polyunsaturated vegetable oils.  There was never adequate scientific data to justify the shift from saturated fats to polyunsaturated vegetable oils.  That was a tragic, unscientific medical error that contributed significantly to deteriorating health in the developed/developing world.

Anti-Inflammatory Diet and Lifestyle Is the Cure

It came as a surprise to me that simply eliminating inflammatory foods could prevent most diseases.  After diseases have developed, it is harder to reverse the process and return to health, but even in that case, diet is of paramount importance.

Back to Basics of a Healthy Diet (the Food Pyramid Is Wrong)

•   Starch/sugar/fructose are inflammatory.  Low carbohydrate is the healthiest diet.
•   Grains, even whole grains, and especially cereal are a big part of the problem and should be avoided.
•   Fat and not carbohydrates, should be the major source of dietary calories/energy.
•   Saturated fats are healthier than vegetable oils -- use olive oil and butter.
•   Meats/fish (not fed on grains) are healthy.  A healthy vegetarian diet is difficult.
•   Leafy vegetables are a good source of healthful antioxidants.
•   Fruits and fructose are inflammatory and should be eaten sparingly.
•   Healthy gut bacteria are important.  Eat fermented foods with live bacteria, e.g. yogurt.

Living with Inflammation

Chronic inflammation can lead to many problems that diet and supplements can help to remedy.  For example, vitamin D deficiency is an epidemic in America, because chronic dietary inflammation appears to compromise the ability to make vitamin D in the skin with sunlight.  Most individuals eating a diet high in polyunsaturated fats, starch and high fructose corn syrup, are deficient in vitamin D and would benefit from a vitamin D3 supplement of at least 2,000 IU per day.  Vitamin D deficiency also contributes to inflammation.  Fish oil supplements can also help to reduce dietary inflammation and should always be taken with at least equal amounts of saturated fats in the same meal.

Resolve to Eat Your Way to Health

It is easy to avoid most diseases by avoiding dietary inflammation.  Since chronic dietary inflammation produces depression, lethargy, obesity and a lack of energy, a healthy anti-inflammatory diet will also lead to weight loss, increased energy and reduced symptoms of aging.  Most symptoms of aging and disease are actually poorly managed inflammation that exposes genetic defects.  Most people increase in inflammation with age, but proper diet can avoid this risk to health and prolong youthful activity.    The healthiest resolution for the new year is to stop eating blatantly inflammatory foods (starch and vegetable oils) and start eating more spicy meats, fish and leafy vegetables.

Cure for Inflammatory Diseases

Destabilizing Gut Biofilms by Simple Remedies

The intercommunication between the gut flora biofilms, the cells of the immune system juxtaposed with the intestinal endothelium and cryptic bacteria/tissue biofilms produces stable chronic inflammatory disease. Disrupting the gut biofilms may permit a resumption of effective immunity and remission.

Disrupting Biofilms to Treat ASDs

Cristian Stremiz brought to my attention the work of Dr. Anju Usman on the treatment of autism spectrum diseases by attacking inflammatory gut biofilms.

A Panacea

This approach, based on the use of common food components, to attack the gut biofilm matrix of acid polysaccharides, cations and proteins, should be generalizable to most inflammatory diseases. The interventions also provide facile explanations for the utility of numerous traditional cures such as vinegar, fiber, glucosamine, pectin, whey, proteases and probiotics.

Cures Act via Gut Flora Biofilms

There are numerous anecdotal reports of traditional, simple remedies working for essentially all diseases. Tantalizingly, many of these diseases are also occasionally successfully treated with antibiotics. The common thread seems to be the involvement of inflammatory gut flora and perhaps cryptic bacteria residing in the tissues displaying symptoms. Glucosamine works sometimes for arthritis, but little of the glucosamine that is eaten reaches the blood stream and the aching joints that seem to become less inflamed. Vinegar, pectin, and fiber have also been attributed with curative powers, yet none is likely to impact inflamed joints directly. Impacting gut biofilms is much easier to explain.

Biofilms of Bacteria Attached to Acidic Polysaccharides and Divalent Cations

Acidic polysaccharides are produced by bacteria and divalent cations cross-link the polysaccharides into a matrix. The bacteria have agglutinins to attach to the matrix. Gut pathogens produce agglutinins that they use to attach to the heparan sulfate (HS), the predominant acid polysaccharide of the intestinal epithelium. Mast cells of the intestines normally release heparin, which is a mixture of HS fragments, to stick to the agglutinins and block attachment to the HS of the epithelium. Numerous bacterial species form complex communities on the polysaccharide matrix and prevent access by antibiotics. Biofilms require 100X the antibiotic concentrations and a cocktail of different antibiotics to eradicate the bacteria.

Biofilms Disrupted by Competing Acid Polysaccharide Fragments and Cation Chelators

The Achille’s heal of biofilms is the ionic interaction between the acidic polysaccharide and divalent cations. This interaction can be attacked by both small fragments of similar acid oligosaccharides, by organic acids that can solubilize the cations, e.g. acidic acid in vinegar, or by chelators, such as EDTA. All of these treatments can remove the calcium, magnesium and iron that is essential to the matrix. Small molecules, such as glucosamine, chondroitin sulfate fragments, heparin, and pectin, can disrupt biofilms. Molecules that bind to heparin or nucleic acids, e.g. berberine, quinine (tonic), methylene blue, should also be effective in disrupting biofilms. [Note that the similarity between amyloid production and biofilms, means that treatments should overlap.] Lactoferrin is effective, since it both binds iron and binds to acidic polysaccharides via its heparin-binding domains.

Proteases Cleave Agglutinins

Stomach proteases, e.g. pepsin, specifically cleave proteins to release heparin-binding, acidic polysaccharide-binding domains that inhibit biofilm production in the stomach. Subsequently, the basic, antimicrobial peptides and agglutinins are cleaved by proteases, e.g. trypsin, that hydrolyze the binding domains. Eating proteases, such as nattokinase present in fermented soybeans, dissolves intestinal biofilms by attacking the agglutinins. The pathogenic E. coli and avian H5N1 also have these agglutinins. It is, therefore, wise to avoid establishing gut biofilms that can immobilize pathogens.

Probiotics Protect Against Biofilms

Resident gut bacteria that produce organic acids, e.g. lactic acid or acetic acid, provide protection against biofilm formation. Examples are the bacteria present in common forms of fermentation and food preservation, e.g. Lactobacillus sp., and the bacterium present in exclusively breastfed babies, Bifidobacter sp. Formula fed babies rapidly develop inflammatory biofilms, which explains their high rates of intestinal and respiratory diseases, as well as increased rates of inflammatory diseases.

Biofilm Inflammation Results in Inflammatory Bowel Disease, etc.

Gut biofilms support system-wide chronic inflammation that leads to allergies, autoimmune diseases, degenerative diseases and probably cancers. This attach on the gut also produces a leaky gut that supplies the bacteria that a moved by macrophages of the gut to all parts of the body. This may be how Chlamydia pneumoniae colonizes sites of inflammation throughout the body.

Attacking Gut Biofilms Is the First Step in the Treatment of All Inflammatory Diseases

Many inflammtory diseases, e.g. chronic lyme disease, rosacea, may be refractory to treatment with antibiotics, because of the reservoir of bacteria in gut biofilms. Attacks on gut biofilms with relatively non-intrusive treatments, such as vinegar, EDTA, lactoferrin and proteases, may lower the total resident pathogen load and make subsequent antibiotic treatment more effective.

Inflammation and Vitamin D Deficiency

Does Dietary Inflammation Reduce Skin Production of Vitamin D?

The media discovered the vitamin D deficiency pandemic last week. Amazingly researchers were recorded on camera saying that the D deficiencies are caused by insufficient exposure to ultraviolet in sunlight and inadequate consumption of vitamin D-laced milk. Have all of these people been avoiding the biomedical journals?

Have they noticed that my tan improved since I started eating anti-inflammatory?

Let’s shine some sunlight on these knowledge deficiencies:

• Serum vitamin D levels have been dropping (as chronic inflammation has been increasing) over the last three decades -- has something changed in our diets?
• Vitamin D deficiencies occur globally (not restricted to Northern latitudes or winter) -- related to diet?
• Women are more vulnerable, because of cultural modesty in some countries, but males are still D-deficient.
• A subset of people exposed to ample sunshine are still D-deficient.
• Vitamin D deficient individuals also have elevated TNF.
• Vitamin D deficiency and inflammation are risk factors in the same diseases.

It seems that the simplest conclusion is that chronic inflammation leads to vitamin D deficiency, even though vitamin D deficiency may also contribute to inflammation.

This also probably means that chronic inflammation makes it harder for skin to produce vitamin D during exposure to sunlight.

One would expect those who are inflamed to get sunburned more readily and people who eat plenty of omega-3 rich seafood probably produce more vitamin D, even if they are not in the sun as much.

Inflammatory starvation (or American fast food) diets high in starch and omega-6 vegetable oils, should produce vitamin D deficiency even on the Equator.

We should not be surprised that inflammatory degenerative diseases are associated with vitamin D deficiency. It would be interesting if vitamin D supplementation to eliminate deficiency, reduced inflammation and reversed degenerative disease.

Do statins reverse vitamin D deficiencies (and improve tanning) as they lower inflammation? [Statin lowering of LDL is unrelated to reduction in cardiovascular disease. Only the anti-inflammatory side-effect is important.]

Does NFkB activation (inflammatory signaling) inhibit vitamin D receptor activity and vice versa?

You can forget all of this confusion, if you just stick with an anti-inflammatory diet (that includes vitamin D supplements) and exercise frequently in the great outdoors.

National Healthcare and Diet

Barack Obama's Anti-Inflammatory Breakfast Pulpit

Trying to improve the health of Americans by taking the advice of the healthcare industry is futile. Barack Obama must set the example of a healthy lifestyle.

The solution is to prevent the diseases that the healthcare industry is using as a source of profits and that means fundamentally changing diets and lifestyles. It has taken three decades to attack health by shifting from meat protein and saturated fats to starch, high fructose corn syrup and polyunsaturated (omega-6) vegetable oils. It will take a sustained, personal effort by President Obama to guide a relatively rapid return to a healthy, anti-inflammatory diet.

All of the degenerative and autoimmune diseases that form the core of current healthcare diagnosis and treatments are rooted in an inflammatory diet and lifestyle dictated by agribusiness and uninformed by science. The media nags about people eating too much and exercising too little. Our obese population is encouraged to lose weight by eating less. Food fat is demonized. Statins are prescribed with religious zeal to lower blood lipids to reduce cardiovascular disease. All of this “health” advice is wrong and unsupported by the biomedical literature.

It is about time for an authority figure, i.e. The President of The United States of America, to use some leadership skills and teach people how to eat and live. That would be much easier than trying to get doctors to order fewer tests from their own medical test companies or order fewer images through their own imaging companies. Are the pharmaceutical companies going to suggest that their pills should cost less and be pushed less frequently? Will the insurance companies step out of their lucrative middleman role between doctor and patient? It is more reasonable for The President to use his bully pulpit to change the U.S. diet and lead us back to health.

All that is needed is for President Obama’s image at the breakfast table to be judiciously used by a private, non-profit organization on a website:

Barack’s Breakfast

This would provide an opportunity for the President’s health agenda to be presented to the world through his prescription (and explanation of health benefits) for each morning meal:

Slow food
Local food
Low carbon footprint
Low carbs
High omega-3 to -6 fatty acid ratio
Praise eggs and saturated fats
Warn about grains

Vitamin D deficiency
No HFCS
No trans fats

Each meal would come with a source and description of each ingredient and its benefits. YouTube videos of the meal preparation could show the techniques needed. Occasionally The President could be seen enjoying the meal and animation could be used to show why hypoglycemic ingredients were used. Maybe The President would show solidarity to the diabetic victims of industry food fights by getting his finger pricked for a blood sugar test after a meal. It would be good to see him complain about the inaccuracy of several different typical meters. Imagine the close-up of all of the lancet marks needed to convince him that the readings are making sense!

This single approach would cost the American people nothing to implement and would save billions of dollars in healthcare expenses over a few years, as citizens of all socio-economic classes changed to diets that were less inflammatory, and degenerative and autoimmune diseases quickly declined.

Chronic Disease, Cryptic Infections, Hibernation

Suppression of Inflammation and Surviving Cytokine Storms

There are numerous unanswered questions in modern medicine. What is aging, for example? Why do people become more inflamed as they age? What’s with all of the chronic, degenerative diseases? Why is lipid metabolism (LDL, HDL, triglycerides) linked to degenerative diseases, along with immune system function and inflammation? I am only going to start the answers here.

I might as well continue to be cryptic and give you the string of words/concepts I am trying to connect to answer the other questions:
Hydrogen sulfide (H2S), endorphins, hibernation, nuclear receptors (PPARs), antibiotics, chronic inflammatory diseases (fibromyalgia, arthritis, chronic fatigue, Lyme, Morgellon’s, Alzheimer’s, prostatitis, pancreatitis, cancers, etc.), autoimmunity, leaky gut/kidney/brain barrier, autism and H1N1.

First a word of advice: Beware of assuming that molecules are specific, i.e. with unique interactions, and that a small molecule will bind to one and only one protein target. [There are lots of bizarre exceptions to the assumption: Aldolase acts as a structural protein for Toxoplasma motility. Fluorescein is added to make protein fluorescent, but the fluorescein is also transported into cells on its own, i.e. fluorescein and rhodamine labeling can give different results. Heparin binds to most extracellular proteins and it is mostly a hydrophobic interaction -- heparin is not just for clotting anymore.]

Observations from the literature:

• Maternal autoimmunity is linked to autism.
• Autism is linked to leaky gut and chronic inflammation.
• Gut/kidney/brain barriers are based on integrity of extracellular matrix (heparan sulfate) that is compromised by inflammation.
• Chronic diseases require inflammation and circulating inflammatory cytokines (TNF, IL-1, IL-6) are elevated..
• NSAIDs induce leaky gut and release of bacteria toward liver.
• Phagocytosis of bacteria leads to transport of some bacteria, e.g. Chlamydia pneumoniae to other sites of inflammation, e.g. gut to joints.
• Opiods can induce hibernation in rodents.
• Sulfides can induce hibernation in rodents.
• H1N1 my cause lethal pneumonia by lung cytokine storm.
• Inflammatory cytokines and inflammation result from activation of NFkB.
• Hibernation involves PPARs (another nuclear receptor transcription factor).
• Omega-3 fatty acids reduce inflammation via COX-2 prostaglandins, but also by binding to PPARs.
• For most of the diseases under consideration, suppression of inflammation will eliminate symptoms.
• Antibiotics can impact all of these diseases in unpredictable ways. In some cases complete remission can be achieved and in other cases antibiotics can produce lethal cytokine storms.
• Bacterial cell wall components, e.g. lipopolysaccharide, lipid A, are intensely pyrogenic, i.e. inflammatory.

Cryptic Bacteria in our Tissues

The role of bacteria in numerous diseases, including cancers, has been proposed since the early isolation of bacteria from human tissues. Many of these bacteria are difficult to culture and have variable forms viewed by microscope. Because these bacteria are difficult for microbiologists to handle with conventional approaches, their existence and significance has always been questioned. Use of antibiotics to treat chronic, inflammatory conditions has seemed inconsistent with the unproven existence of a bacterial cause. Thus, there is surprise when the inappropriate use of antibiotics leads to a cure.

Cryptic Bacteria Suppress Local Inflammation and Promote Chronic Inflammation

I think that the fundamental problem is the assumption that human tissue is sterile, i.e. free from microorganisms, such as bacteria, unless there is overt infection. Part of the sterile assumption derives from the intense inflammatory response to bacteria. In order for bacteria to survive in tissue, the bacteria must suppress inflammation and the tissue must tolerate the slow leaching of inflammatory bacterial materials.

Chronic Disease Hypothesis

Based on the cryptic bacterial infection hypothesis, many, if not all chronic diseases are initiated by inflammatory events that release bacteria into the blood stream carried in phagocytic cells. The cells migrate and take up residence at a region of inflammation. The bacteria produce molecules that produce tissue hibernation and quell local inflammation in response to the bacteria. The bacteria are, however, a source of ongoing irritation to the tissue and a chronic inflammatory disease results.

Eradication of Cryptic Bacteria

Antibiotics would be a typical choice for killing infecting bacteria. In the case of cryptic, chronic infections, however, application of therapeutic antibiotics may be problematic. The established infections may have produced privileged locations isolated from the vascular system and protected by a bacterial community, e.g. a biofilm. Alternatively, the death of the bacteria and release of pyrogenic factors my produce life-threatening inflammation, that requires careful support.

Hibernation in Rodents Provides Treatment Clues

The compromise of tissue inflammation in response to cryptic bacteria is similar to the physiology of rodent hibernation. In both cases, systemic inflammation is suppressed. At the cellular level, this means that other signaling pathways silence the inflammatory NFkB expression pattern. One of the major nuclear receptors that is activated in hibernation is PPAR. PPAR is activated by opiods and H2S, which also induce hibernation in rodents. There are numerous analogs, inhibitors and H2S donors that could be used to disrupt hibernation (free local suppression of inflammation) or reduce symptoms by suppressing systemic inflammation.

Inflammation Compromises Tissue/Blood Barriers

Inflammation causes a disruption of the integrity of the endothelial extracellular matrix at sites of local inflammation. NFkB activation shuts down the expression of genes involved in heparan sulfate proteoglycan (HSPG) synthesis makes the tissue/blood barrier leaky. Locally this facilitates the recruitment of lymphocytes and neutrophils for defense, but systemically it leads to leaky gut/kidney/brain barriers that permit bacteria to cross.

Convergence of Therapies to Attack Cryptic Infections

The central approaches to attack cryptic infections are a combination of antibiotics and suppression of cytokine storms. These approaches are used in Marshall’s Protocol [http://bacteriality.com/ ], which also exploits a vitamin D receptor antagonist, Olmesartan, that also inhibits NFkB and inflammation.

A similar protocol has been developed by Dr. Michael Powell to inhibit hibernation and attack cryptic infections:
http://www.faqs.org/patents/app/20090163448

These approaches are similar to the lengthy use of antibiotics for the treatment of chronic Lyme disease.

It is very interesting to note that some of the most effective treatments for a long list of degenerative chronic diseases, autoimmune diseases and cancers, use essentially the same protocol that should attack cryptic bacteria and provide support for ensuing inflammation.

Diet, Nutrition and Health

These are my generalizations (some would say prejudices) from 40 years of experience in plant biochemistry and molecular biology:

Plant Secondary Compounds Are Defensive and Toxic

The development of plant secondary compounds (all of the compounds that are not part of metabolism or structures) is in response to pathogens, herbivores and pollinator/disseminator attractants -- development of these compounds has nothing to do with humans. Examples: Nicotine and caffeine are very toxic to herbivores and are present in plants for protection. Humans learn to play with toxic plant chemicals, just as they have learned to play with fire and explosives.

Plants Are Not There For Us

People have learned to exploit local plants for protection against local human pathogens, but there is no selective advantage to plants (except for domesticated plants) for useful plants to grow near humans. This logic would suggest that rats and mosquitoes, that flourish near human habitations, are there because of their human utility. Human live near places were useful plants grow.

Grains Are Unhealthy

One of the biggest problems with food processing is separating the inflammatory parts = starch and omega-6 oils, from the nutritive parts, the so-called anti-oxidants, vitamins, proteins, etc. Grains, even so-called whole grains, are simply too enriched for starch and inflammatory oils to be healthy. They are not safe to eat in large amounts. Leafy plant parts are healthy, but even those parts are not good in large amounts from a single plant species. Humans are browsers, because the plant secondary compounds are uniformly toxic, but can be tolerated better in a mixture of different toxicities.

Starch Is Inflammatory

Starchy foods should be treated like a fish. The starch should be pared away and discarded, like the fish gut and bones. (The guts and bones could actually be processed to make them nutritious. Not so with the starch. The starch should be fermented.) The potato skin should be eaten and the rest discarded, just as an aphid secretes as honey dew the extra sugar it sucks in from a plant leaf.

Cereals Are Inflammatory

Breakfast cereals are a dietary abomination. They contribute immensely to obesity, inflammation and chronic disease. Oatmeal for cardiovascular health is a total fraud. The fiber might be useful, but the high starch causes cardiovascular disease. Grains/cereal are the foundation of the chronic disease pyramid.

Fructose is Toxic

Fruit juices are another fraud. The juice (fructose) should be removed and discarded. The fructose is very unhealthy. Mice are given type II diabetes for research purposes by feeding them fructose (especially high fructose corn syrup.) Fructose is avoided in the beef industry, because it causes rapid cross-linking of collagen and leads to tough meat. The same thing happens in humans who eat fructose, it causes aging of the skin and other tissues. High fructose corn syrup is a commercial addiction -- it is hugely profitable as a sweetener -- and that is why it is still used, even though it is grossly unhealthy. It will eventually be removed from the market after the industry is protected from subsequent law suits. It is equivalent to the tobacco industry -- too lucrative to eliminate.

Phytic Acid

The active ingredient in fiber that provides its benefits is phytic acid, the same chemical that people are trying to eliminate. Phytic acid acts as a chelator. I don't think it is actually a problem. The problem comes from extracting cations from the phytic acid before it is eaten. Phytic acid should go in saturated, so that it doesn't contribute to deficiencies. The actual problem is that the diet is already low in minerals, because of eating processed foods that are mineral deficient.

Enzymatic Detoxification: P450, Glycosylation and Secretion

Humans are adapted to plant secondary metabolites by the abiltiy to enzymatically detoxify [using p450 and glycosylating (adding glucuronic acid)] and secrete the toxic compounds. These chemical modifications that occur in the intestines and liver are usually effect. They also work on drugs and that is how we eventually clear these compounds from our systems. Grapefruit and black pepper inactivate these enzymes and alter the way we metabolize plant toxins and drugs. The detox enzymes can also convert innocuous compounds into toxins and carcinogens. That conversion is the basis for using liver enzymes in the Ames Test for carcinogens. The activity of the enzymes is dependent on recent diet, so it would make sense to gradually change the amount and type of vegetables that are eaten in a meal to permit the detox system to adjust.

Glucose and Insulin Cause Fat Accumulation

Fat accumulation is dependent on dietary carbohydrates and insulin. Fat and serum lipids accumulates with a high carbohydrate diet and decrease on a low carbohydrate diet. This is more important than the number of calories consumed.

Inflammation Not Serum Lipids Cause CVD: Statin Are Unnecessary

Inflammation is the source of chronic degenerative diseases. Serum lipids are only secondary factors. Statins lower serum lipids, but do not impact cardiovascular health unless they also lower inflammation. Lowering inflammation lowers serum lipids and decreases cardiovascular disease. Statins appear to be a very expensive way of treating cardiovascular disease dependent on their side effect on inflammation. Modest dietary and lifestyle changes are much more effective, cheap and safe than statins.

Inflammatory Protection from Swine Flu

Inflammation causes allergies, autoimmune and degenerative diseases, and is the foundation for cancer, but it does provide protection against infection.

One of the reasons that older people are less prone to infectious diseases, is that their immune systems have already been exposed to earlier versions of pathogens. Another reason for the relative good health of the parents of baby boomers, is that chronic inflammation increases with age and protection against pathogens is the adaptive advantage of inflammation.

As of now, the new swine flu pre-epidemic is very scary in Mexico City, but doesn’t pack much of a punch north of the border. Maybe it is too early to be optimistic, but it is tantalizing to speculate that the diet-based chronic inflammation that stuffs the coffins in the US, may be good for something besides stuffing the coffers of agribusiness.

One of the symptoms of high chronic inflammation is many years without a day of sick leave. It is hard for a pathogen to get a foothold when the immune system is already provoked by inflammation. Even food and harmless pollen is attacked with vigor and lots of sneezing.

Swine flu is attacking the young and healthy in Mexico. King Corn has already wiped out those targets in the US. Obesity fed by starch, vegetable oils and corn-fed meat, produces chronic inflammation and a potential resistance to swine flu. The US diet provides the inflammatory benefits of old age for the young.

This explains why I live in Idaho. Here it is easy to maintain an island of health in a sea of inflammation. Few visitors with infectious diseases can travel from healthy countries fast enough to transmit the diseases before they show symptoms. Everyone else who reads my advice, lowers their inflammation and lives longer, healthier lives free of chronic diseases, had better start washing their hands and wearing face masks.

Cure for Cancer, Autoimmunity, Allergies, etc.

The immune system is powerful enough to provide protection from disease. Unfortunately, to act decisively the cells of the immune system have to be able to discriminate between self and non-self. Poor discrimination can lead to autoimmunity, cancer or infection. New approaches promise the precise use of interleukins, to reset self-recognition, eliminate a wide range of diseases and liberalize organ transplantation.

IL-2 is the Cytokine Responsible for Suppression of Autoimmunity -- Tolerance

Self/non-self discrimination is dependent on cellular communication and much of that communication takes place via small proteins called interleukins. First and foremost among the interleukins is interleukin-2 (IL-2). IL-2 is made by cells of the immune system, lymphocytes. Mice that are either defective in producing IL-2 or the lymphocyte receptor for IL-2, IL2R alpha, also called CD25, rapidly develop autoimmune diseases, such as type I diabetes or inflammatory bowel disease. Thus IL-2 is necessary for both effective immunological defenses against pathogens and suppression of immune attacks on self tissues, i.e. autoimmunity.

IL-2 Balance Achieved with Complex of IL-2 and Anti-IL-2 Antibodies

Direct injection of IL-2 has some impact on cancers, but is very difficult to control. This should be expected, because local environments should determine if the IL-2 will stimulate aggressive immunological attacks or development of regulatory T cells, Tregs, that produce tolerance.

More subtle control is achieved by using antibodies that bind to particular regions of the IL-2. The resulting IL-2/anti-IL-2 complexes can be used to stimulate immunological reactions to an antigen, which is useful for vaccines, or can stimulate tolerance for use in organ transplantation.

Future applications may be in the cure of a wide variety of autoimmune diseases, e.g. type I diabetes, inflammatory bowel diseases, allergies, asthma; degenerative diseases, such as arthritis or athersclerosis, and cancers.

reference:
Webster KE, Walters S, Kohler RE, Mrkvan T, Boyman O, Surh CD, Grey ST, Sprent J. 2009. In vivo expansion of T reg cells with IL-2-mAb complexes: induction of resistance to EAE and long-term acceptance of islet allografts without immunosuppression. J Exp Med. Mar 30. [Epub ahead of print]

Inflammation Causes Disease

Human diets have changed dramatically over the last few hundred years, and as a consequence so have our diseases. The most recent shift in diet over the last hundred years has resulted in a shift from infectious diseases to degenerative diseases. This trend is summarized in the following Wikipedia entry.

Lifestyle diseases, from Wikipedia:

"Lifestyle diseases (also called diseases of longevity or diseases of civilization) are diseases that appear to increase in frequency as countries become more industrialized and people live longer. They include Alzheimer's disease, atherosclerosis, asthma, cancer, chronic liver disease or cirrhosis, Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease, Type 2 diabetes, heart disease, nephritis or chronic renal failure, osteoporosis, acne, stroke, depression and obesity.

Death statistics in the United States
In 1900, the top three causes of death in the United States were pneumonia/influenza, tuberculosis, and diarrhea/enteritis. Communicable diseases accounted for about 60 percent of all deaths. In 1900, heart disease and cancer were ranked number four and eight respectively. Since the 1940s, the majority of deaths in the United States have resulted from heart disease, cancer, and other degenerative diseases. And, by the late 1990s, degenerative diseases accounted for more than 60 percent of all deaths.
Reference:
National Center for Health Statistics, National Office of Vital Statistics, 1947 for the year 1900 (page 67), for the year 1938 (page 55)."

My point here is that all of the so-called lifestyle diseases are also based on inflammation. I checked the research literature for studies of the response of each of these diseases to diets supplemented with omega-3 fish oils. Studies had been performed in each case. Reduction of inflammation by fish oil treatment was uniformly effective in reducing symptoms of all of the degenerative diseases. Other diseases that can be added to the inflammatory list are spinal disc problems and hypertension. It is interesting that disc dislocations are associated with coeliac, an inflammatory/autoimmune disease. It is also interesting that acne and depression are listed. Acne is indirectly associated with diet, but if sufferers shift to an anti-inflammatory diet, acne symptoms disappear. Depression associated with childbirth is particularly responsive to anti-inflammatory drugs, diet and exercise. Most of the symptoms associated with aging are just due to inflammation and are similarly responsive to anti-inflammatory lifestyle changes

To summarize:

• Modern degenerative diseases are caused by modern inflammatory diets (and insufficient exercise.)
• Anti-inflammatory diet and lifestyle reduce degenerative diseases.
• Aging is predominantly mismanaged inflammation.