Anti-Inflammatory Diet

All health care starts with diet. My recommendations for a healthy diet are here:
Anti-Inflammatory Diet and Lifestyle.
There are over 190 articles on diet, inflammation and disease on this blog
(find topics using search [upper left] or index [lower right]), and
more articles by Prof. Ayers on Suite101 .

Thursday, February 19, 2009

Aricept: dementia treatment

Aromatic Binding to Enzymes -- 

Aricept, an acetylcholine esterase inhibitor used to treat Alzheimer’s disease and other conditions that benefit from enhanced accumulation of acetylcholine, is an example of a molecule with multiple hydrophobic rings that binds to an enzyme.

I want to discuss aricept as an arbitrary example that I just looked up to illustrate the lack of specificity of statins that I will characterize in another article as little more than molecular skeleton keys that work on many different enzymes.

I have presented two diagrams of the structure of Aricept. It has two isolated rings on the left and then a fused pair of rings on the right. The major chemical feature here is the inability of the rings to hydrogen bond with water. The result is that water next to the faces of the rings is highly structured in a high energy configuration. Two rings will be at a much lower energy if they are stacked together, because two of the surfaces will no longer be exposed to water.

Typical low energy, noncovalent bonds in water, such as ionic bonds are readily broken by the thermal, kinetic energy of water -- they get knocked apart. The energy of these bonds is only 1-2 kcal/mol. In contrast, the stacked hydrophobic rings are quite stable, because it takes ten times the energy to separate them, 20 kcal/mol.

Aricept binds to acetylcholine esterase, the enzyme that degrades the neurotransmitter acetylcholine by at least three stacked rings. These ring structures are shown in the close up of the tunnel leading to the enzymes active site near the yellow tryptophan on the left. Part of the enzyme shown by the white, ribbon-like twists of the amino acid backbone have been removed over the tope of the grey-red and blue aricept molecule, to make it easier to see.

I also showed the aricept in the tunnel with the surface of the protein shown to indicate how the aricept slips and sticks in the enzyme and blocks its activity.

The aricept is bound to yellow tryptophans at both ends and the middle ring is bound to the hydrophobic ring of orange tyrosine. The geometry of the interaction is important, but many other molecules with fewer rings would also bind to the same hydrophobic, aromatic ring amino acids. Acetylcholine, which can form hydrogen bonds with the paired electons of the acetyl oxygens, will just slip across the surface of the hydrophobic rings on its way into the enzymatic tunnel.

Statins were found by testing fungal extracts for molecules that would inhibit an enzyme (HMG-CoA reductase) in lipid metabolism. The normal lipid substrates for that enzyme would also be expected to bind to the surface of rings in the acetylcholine esterase enzyme. In fact, I would expect to find molecules from fungal extracts that would inhibit acetylcholine esterase.

I demonstrated the nonspecificity of all of these binding events with the aromatic rings in the active sites of enzymes by having one of my students check for the binding of a flat hydrophobic molecule, metformin, one of the common drugs for treating type II diabetes, to a common bacterial enzyme, beta galactosidase. Kinetic studies demonstrated competitive inhibition of typical beta galactosidase substrates, which indicates that the metformin binds the aromatic amino acids that are known to be involved in binding of the sugar substrates, e.g. lactose, of the enzyme. I would not be surprised if the statins are transported into cells by the same organic cationic transporter that transports metformin.

I am setting the stage for a discussion in a future article of what kind of activities would be expected from fungal molecules that were identified by the statin screening. It is not surprising that the statins have many activities other than reducing LDL. The only statins that are effective in treating cardiovascular disease are those that also lower inflammation. It is also not surprising that statins have many side-effects.

8 comments:

Nigel Kinbrum BSc(Hons)Eng said...

This is all highly relevant to my mum, who's only just re-started taking Aricept after 8 days of not taking it.

I found an acetylcholinesterase inhibitor called Huperzine A. 50mcg/day of Huperzine A is supposedly an effective dose, compared to 5mg/day for Aricept. Huperzine A is ~£13 for 60 days supply compared to Aricept which is ~£60 for 28 days supply. Have you studied Huperzine A?

Dr. Art Ayers said...

Nigel,
My article was a response to your note about your mother's use of Aricept. I just used it as an instant example to demonstrate that any randomly chosen molecule will show some binding to dozens of common enzymes. I just looked up Aricept in the structure database and since someone paid to show that it is effective in blocking acetylcholine esterase, the structure was there.
Huperzine A shows that there is heavy selection pressure on plants to produce molecules that are highly effective in binding to animal enzymes. Each drug has hundreds of interactions that differ for each person and change with physiology. It is all a wicked empirical game.
I can't claim expertise in predicting outcomes. Was the sudden withdrawal of Aricept and the resulting suite of changed interactions the problem? Changing to Huperzine would provide a new suite of interactions. Good or bad? It is all dependent on too many variables. My prejudice is to get her back into as normal a routine as possible and try to reinforce the normal behaviors.
I just hope that your mum's condition improves.

Nigel Kinbrum BSc(Hons)Eng said...

There were two things going on at the same time. The UTI caused initial increasing confusion resulting in mum discontinuing Aricept which caused additional increasing confusion until she collapsed and couldn't get up.

I'm hoping that correcting both of the above problems will restore her mental faculties to close to their previous level. Correcting the UTI alone has not restored much of her mental faculties and she was fairly unresponsive on Wednesday. While mum is in hospital, I am unable to give her Vit D3, curcumin, berberine or lots of smoked salmon, which may hinder her progress.

As it's difficult to tweak the dose of Aricept (it's only available as 5mg & 10mg pills and 10mg/day caused bad side-effects last year), I considered the use of low-dose Huperzine A (50mcg/week, say) to "top-up" the inhibition of acetylcholinesterase by Aricept.

There's always the possibility of unwanted interaction between the two substances, so I will be treading very carefully.

Dr. Art Ayers said...

Nigel,
I agree with your approach.
I also need to pursue my major point about these drugs. I am not concerned about the interactions between the drugs, but rather the fact that neither drug is specific for acetylcholine esterase. The drugs affect dozens of other essential signaling and metabolic components and the side effects of each are different. I doubt that they are interchangeable and Aricept withdrawal can only be partially compensated by Huperizine A. Most of the impact on mental function probably has nothing to do with acetylcholine levels.
Your vigilance in supporting her anti-inflammatory diet probably compensated for the tendency of Aricept to cause UTIs and intestinal flareups.
I think that the UTI antibiotics will not be as hard on her gut flora as other antibiotics, but probiotic support should also be considered.
Best of luck.

Nigel Kinbrum BSc(Hons)Eng said...

I can't give mum any supplements while she's in hospital, so I have to wait until the Aricept takes effect and hope that it's effective on its own to get her into a mental state fit enough to be allowed to go home.

Homeopath said...

Interesting blog......

Anonymous said...

You were correct in predicting that statins and metformin are transported into the liver via the same organic anion transporting proteins. This transporter protein is encoded by the SLCO gene. Mutations within this protein family SLCO1B1 (domain OATP), are predicted to occur in 20% to 38% of the caucasian population, exposing a large % of the caucasian population (study of population genetics looking at this mutation was done in Finland) to greatly increased plasma levels of these drugs. Statin toxicities can run the gamut from mild myopathies (the lucky ones), peripheral neuropathies, rhabdomyolysis, and lastly most troubling and destructive(unless death results from the rhabdomyolysis), neurodegenerative diseases. Except for the association between variations in SLCO1B1, statin use and myopathies, the other adverse effects are not being studied, esp the neurodegenerative ones .

Anna said...

Hi,
I am The editor/writer with physician.com. I really liked your site and i am interested in building a relationship with your site. We want to spread public awareness. I hope you can help me out. Your site is a very useful resource.

Please email me back with your URl in subject line to take a step ahead and also to avoid spam.

Thank you,
Anna Huges
editorial.physician@gmail.com
www.physician.com